Ecosyste.ms: Awesome

An open API service indexing awesome lists of open source software.

Awesome Lists | Featured Topics | Projects

https://github.com/modelscope/evalscope

A streamlined and customizable framework for efficient large model evaluation and performance benchmarking
https://github.com/modelscope/evalscope

evaluation llm performance

Last synced: about 1 month ago
JSON representation

A streamlined and customizable framework for efficient large model evaluation and performance benchmarking

Host: GitHub
URL: https://github.com/modelscope/evalscope
Owner: modelscope
License: apache-2.0
Created: 2023-12-07T06:10:49.000Z (10 months ago)
Default Branch: main
Last Pushed: 2024-08-13T08:41:40.000Z (about 1 month ago)
Last Synced: 2024-08-13T08:42:34.847Z (about 1 month ago)
Topics: evaluation, llm, performance
Language: Python
Homepage:
Size: 3.05 MB
Stars: 137
Watchers: 7
Forks: 18
Open Issues: 13
Metadata Files:
- Readme: README.md
- License: LICENSE

Awesome Lists containing this project

awesome-production-machine-learning - EvalScope - EvalScope is a streamlined and customizable framework for efficient large model evaluation and performance benchmarking. (Evaluation and Observability)

README

English | [简体中文](README_zh.md)

![](resources/evalscope.jpeg)

## 📖 Table of Contents
- [Introduction](#introduction)
- [News](#News)
- [Installation](#installation)
- [Quick Start](#quick-start)
- [Dataset List](#datasets-list)
- [Leaderboard](#leaderboard)
- [Experiments and Results](#Experiments-and-Results)
- [Model Serving Performance Evaluation](#Model-Serving-Performance-Evaluation)

## 📝 Introduction

Large Language Model (LLMs) evaluation has become a critical process for assessing and improving LLMs. To better support the evaluation of large models, we propose the EvalScope framework, which includes the following components and features:

![](resources/evalscope_framework.png?raw=true)
*EvalScope Framework.*

- Pre-configured common benchmark datasets, including: MMLU, CMMLU, C-Eval, GSM8K, ARC, HellaSwag, TruthfulQA, MATH, HumanEval, etc.
- Implementation of common evaluation metrics
- Unified model integration, compatible with the generate and chat interfaces of multiple model series
- Automatic evaluation (evaluator):
- Automatic evaluation for objective questions
- Implementation of complex task evaluation using expert models
- Reports of evaluation generating
- Arena mode
- Visualization tools
- Model Inference Performance Evaluation [Tutorial](evalscope/perf/README.md)
- Support for OpenCompass as an Evaluation Backend, featuring advanced encapsulation and task simplification to easily submit tasks to OpenCompass for evaluation.
- Supports VLMEvalKit as the evaluation backend. It initiates VLMEvalKit's multimodal evaluation tasks through EvalScope, supporting various multimodal models and datasets.
- Full pipeline support: Seamlessly integrate with SWIFT to easily train and deploy model services, initiate evaluation tasks, view evaluation reports, and achieve an end-to-end large model development process.

**Features**
- Lightweight, minimizing unnecessary abstractions and configurations
- Easy to customize
- New datasets can be integrated by simply implementing a single class
- Models can be hosted on [ModelScope](https://modelscope.cn), and evaluations can be initiated with just a model id
- Supports deployment of locally hosted models
- Visualization of evaluation reports
- Rich evaluation metrics
- Model-based automatic evaluation process, supporting multiple evaluation modes
- Single mode: Expert models score individual models
- Pairwise-baseline mode: Comparison with baseline models
- Pairwise (all) mode: Pairwise comparison of all models

## 🎉 News
- **[2024.07.31]** Breaking change: The sdk name has been changed from `llmuses` to `evalscope`, please update the sdk name in your code.
- **[2024.07.26]** Supports **VLMEvalKit** as a third-party evaluation framework, initiating multimodal model evaluation tasks. [User Guide](#vlmevalkit-evaluation-backend) 🔥🔥🔥
- **[2024.06.29]** Supports **OpenCompass** as a third-party evaluation framework. We have provided a high-level wrapper, supporting installation via pip and simplifying the evaluation task configuration. [User Guide](#opencompass-evaluation-backend) 🔥🔥🔥
- **[2024.06.13]** EvalScope has been updated to version 0.3.x, which supports the ModelScope SWIFT framework for LLMs evaluation. 🚀🚀🚀
- **[2024.06.13]** We have supported the ToolBench as a third-party evaluation backend for Agents evaluation. 🚀🚀🚀

## 🛠️ Installation
### Install with pip
1. create conda environment [Optional]
```shell
conda create -n evalscope python=3.10
conda activate evalscope
```

2. Install EvalScope
```shell
pip install evalscope # Installation with Native backend (by default)

pip install evalscope[opencompass] # Installation with OpenCompass backend
pip install evalscope[vlmeval] # Installation with VLMEvalKit backend
pip install evalscope[all] # Installation with all backends (Native, OpenCompass, VLMEvalKit)
```

DEPRECATION WARNING: For 0.4.3 or older versions, please use the following command to install:
```shell
pip install llmuses<=0.4.3

# Usage:
from llmuses.run import run_task
...

```

### Install from source code
1. Download source code
```shell
git clone https://github.com/modelscope/evalscope.git
```

2. Install dependencies
```shell
cd evalscope/
pip install -e .
```

## 🚀 Quick Start

### Simple Evaluation
command line with pip installation:
```shell
python -m evalscope.run --model ZhipuAI/chatglm3-6b --template-type chatglm3 --datasets arc --limit 100
```
command line with source code:
```shell
python evalscope/run.py --model ZhipuAI/chatglm3-6b --template-type chatglm3 --datasets mmlu ceval --limit 10
```
Parameters:
- --model: ModelScope model id, model link: [ZhipuAI/chatglm3-6b](https://modelscope.cn/models/ZhipuAI/chatglm3-6b/summary)

### Evaluation with Model Arguments
```shell
python evalscope/run.py --model ZhipuAI/chatglm3-6b --template-type chatglm3 --model-args revision=v1.0.2,precision=torch.float16,device_map=auto --datasets mmlu ceval --use-cache true --limit 10
```
```shell
python evalscope/run.py --model qwen/Qwen-1_8B --generation-config do_sample=false,temperature=0.0 --datasets ceval --dataset-args '{"ceval": {"few_shot_num": 0, "few_shot_random": false}}' --limit 10
```
Parameters:
- --model-args: Parameters of model: revision, precision, device_map, in format of key=value,key=value
- --datasets: datasets list, separated by space
- --use-cache: `true` or `false`, whether to use cache, default is `false`
- --dataset-args: evaluation settings，json format，key is the dataset name，value should be args for the dataset
- --few_shot_num: few-shot data number
- --few_shot_random: whether to use random few-shot data, default is `true`
- --local_path: local dataset path
- --limit: maximum number of samples to evaluate for each sub-dataset
- --template-type: model template type, see [Template Type List](https://github.com/modelscope/swift/blob/main/docs/source_en/LLM/Supported-models-datasets.md)

Note: you can use following command to check the template type list of the model:
```shell
from evalscope.models.template import TemplateType
print(TemplateType.get_template_name_list())
```

### Evaluation Backend
EvalScope supports using third-party evaluation frameworks to initiate evaluation tasks, which we call Evaluation Backend. Currently supported Evaluation Backend includes:
- **Native**: EvalScope's own **default evaluation framework**, supporting various evaluation modes including single model evaluation, arena mode, and baseline model comparison mode.
- [OpenCompass](https://github.com/open-compass/opencompass): Initiate OpenCompass evaluation tasks through EvalScope. Lightweight, easy to customize, supports seamless integration with the LLM fine-tuning framework [ModelScope Swift](https://github.com/modelscope/swift).
- [VLMEvalKit](https://github.com/open-compass/VLMEvalKit): Initiate VLMEvalKit multimodal evaluation tasks through EvalScope. Supports various multimodal models and datasets, and offers seamless integration with the LLM fine-tuning framework [ModelScope Swift](https://github.com/modelscope/swift).
- **ThirdParty**: The third-party task, e.g. [ToolBench](evalscope/thirdparty/toolbench/README.md), you can contribute your own evaluation task to EvalScope as third-party backend.

#### OpenCompass Eval-Backend

To facilitate the use of the OpenCompass evaluation backend, we have customized the OpenCompass source code and named it `ms-opencompass`. This version includes optimizations for evaluation task configuration and execution based on the original version, and it supports installation via PyPI. This allows users to initiate lightweight OpenCompass evaluation tasks through EvalScope. Additionally, we have initially opened up API-based evaluation tasks in the OpenAI API format. You can deploy model services using [ModelScope Swift](https://github.com/modelscope/swift), where [swift deploy](https://swift.readthedocs.io/en/latest/LLM/VLLM-inference-acceleration-and-deployment.html) supports using vLLM to launch model inference services.

##### Installation
```shell
# Install with extra option
pip install evalscope[opencompass]
```

##### Data Preparation
Available datasets from OpenCompass backend:
```text
'obqa', 'AX_b', 'siqa', 'nq', 'mbpp', 'winogrande', 'mmlu', 'BoolQ', 'cluewsc', 'ocnli', 'lambada', 'CMRC', 'ceval', 'csl', 'cmnli', 'bbh', 'ReCoRD', 'math', 'humaneval', 'eprstmt', 'WSC', 'storycloze', 'MultiRC', 'RTE', 'chid', 'gsm8k', 'AX_g', 'bustm', 'afqmc', 'piqa', 'lcsts', 'strategyqa', 'Xsum', 'agieval', 'ocnli_fc', 'C3', 'tnews', 'race', 'triviaqa', 'CB', 'WiC', 'hellaswag', 'summedits', 'GaokaoBench', 'ARC_e', 'COPA', 'ARC_c', 'DRCD'
```
Refer to [OpenCompass datasets](https://hub.opencompass.org.cn/home)

You can use the following code to list all available datasets:
```python
from evalscope.backend.opencompass import OpenCompassBackendManager
print(f'** All datasets from OpenCompass backend: {OpenCompassBackendManager.list_datasets()}')
```

Dataset download:
- Option1: Download from ModelScope
```shell
git clone https://www.modelscope.cn/datasets/swift/evalscope_resource.git
```

- Option2: Download from OpenCompass GitHub
```shell
wget https://github.com/open-compass/opencompass/releases/download/0.2.2.rc1/OpenCompassData-complete-20240207.zip
```

Unzip the file and set the path to the `data` directory in current work directory.

##### Model Serving
We use ModelScope swift to deploy model services, see: [ModelScope Swift](hhttps://swift.readthedocs.io/en/latest/LLM/VLLM-inference-acceleration-and-deployment.html)
```shell
# Install ms-swift
pip install ms-swift

# Deploy model
CUDA_VISIBLE_DEVICES=0 swift deploy --model_type llama3-8b-instruct --port 8000
```

##### Model Evaluation

Refer to example: [example_eval_swift_openai_api](examples/example_eval_swift_openai_api.py) to configure and execute the evaluation task:
```shell
python examples/example_eval_swift_openai_api.py
```

#### VLMEvalKit Evaluation Backend

To facilitate the use of the VLMEvalKit evaluation backend, we have customized the VLMEvalKit source code and named it `ms-vlmeval`. This version encapsulates the configuration and execution of evaluation tasks based on the original version and supports installation via PyPI, allowing users to initiate lightweight VLMEvalKit evaluation tasks through EvalScope. Additionally, we support API-based evaluation tasks in the OpenAI API format. You can deploy multimodal model services using ModelScope [swift](https://github.com/modelscope/swift).

##### Installation
```shell
# Install with additional options
pip install evalscope[vlmeval]
```

##### Data Preparation
Currently supported datasets include:
```text
'COCO_VAL', 'MME', 'HallusionBench', 'POPE', 'MMBench_DEV_EN', 'MMBench_TEST_EN', 'MMBench_DEV_CN', 'MMBench_TEST_CN', 'MMBench', 'MMBench_CN', 'MMBench_DEV_EN_V11', 'MMBench_TEST_EN_V11', 'MMBench_DEV_CN_V11', 'MMBench_TEST_CN_V11', 'MMBench_V11', 'MMBench_CN_V11', 'SEEDBench_IMG', 'SEEDBench2', 'SEEDBench2_Plus', 'ScienceQA_VAL', 'ScienceQA_TEST', 'MMT-Bench_ALL_MI', 'MMT-Bench_ALL', 'MMT-Bench_VAL_MI', 'MMT-Bench_VAL', 'AesBench_VAL', 'AesBench_TEST', 'CCBench', 'AI2D_TEST', 'MMStar', 'RealWorldQA', 'MLLMGuard_DS', 'BLINK', 'OCRVQA_TEST', 'OCRVQA_TESTCORE', 'TextVQA_VAL', 'DocVQA_VAL', 'DocVQA_TEST', 'InfoVQA_ VAL', 'InfoVQA_TEST', 'ChartQA_VAL', 'ChartQA_TEST', 'MathVision', 'MathVision_MINI', 'MMMU_DEV_VAL', 'MMMU_TEST', 'OCRBench', 'MathVista_MINI', 'LLaVABench', 'MMVet', 'MTVQA_TEST', 'MMLongBench_DOC', 'VCR_EN_EASY_500', 'VCR_EN_EASY_100', 'VCR_EN_EASY_ALL', 'VCR_EN_HARD_500', 'VCR_EN_HARD_100', 'VCR_EN_HARD_ALL', 'VCR_ZH_EASY_500', 'VCR_ZH_EASY_100', 'VCR_Z H_EASY_ALL', 'VCR_ZH_HARD_500', 'VCR_ZH_HARD_100', 'VCR_ZH_HARD_ALL', 'MMBench-Video', 'Video-MME', 'MMBench_DEV_EN', 'MMBench_TEST_EN', 'MMBench_DEV_CN', 'MMBench_TEST_CN', 'MMBench', 'MMBench_CN', 'MMBench_DEV_EN_V11', 'MMBench_TEST_EN_V11', 'MMBench_DEV_CN_V11', 'MMBench_TEST_CN_V11', 'MM Bench_V11', 'MMBench_CN_V11', 'SEEDBench_IMG', 'SEEDBench2', 'SEEDBench2_Plus', 'ScienceQA_VAL', 'ScienceQA_TEST', 'MMT-Bench_ALL_MI', 'MMT-Bench_ALL', 'MMT-Bench_VAL_MI', 'MMT-Bench_VAL', 'AesBench_VAL', 'AesBench_TEST', 'CCBench', 'AI2D_TEST', 'MMStar', 'RealWorldQA', 'MLLMGuard_DS', 'BLINK'
```
For detailed information about the datasets, please refer to [VLMEvalKit Supported Multimodal Evaluation Sets](https://github.com/open-compass/VLMEvalKit/tree/main#-datasets-models-and-evaluation-results).

You can use the following to view the list of dataset names:
```python
from evalscope.backend.vlm_eval_kit import VLMEvalKitBackendManager
print(f'** All models from VLMEvalKit backend: {VLMEvalKitBackendManager.list_supported_models().keys()}')

```
If the dataset file does not exist locally when loading the dataset, it will be automatically downloaded to the `~/LMUData/` directory.

##### Model Evaluation
There are two ways to evaluate the model:

###### 1. ModelScope Swift Deployment for Model Evaluation
**Model Deployment**
Deploy the model service using ModelScope Swift. For detailed instructions, refer to: [ModelScope Swift MLLM Deployment Guide](https://swift.readthedocs.io/en/latest/Multi-Modal/mutlimodal-deployment.html)
```shell
# Install ms-swift
pip install ms-swift
# Deploy the qwen-vl-chat multi-modal model service
CUDA_VISIBLE_DEVICES=0 swift deploy --model_type qwen-vl-chat --model_id_or_path models/Qwen-VL-Chat
```
**Model Evaluation**
Refer to the example file: [example_eval_vlm_swift](examples/example_eval_vlm_swift.py) to configure the evaluation task.
Execute the evaluation task:
```shell
python examples/example_eval_vlm_swift.py
```

###### 2. Local Model Inference Evaluation
**Model Inference Evaluation**
Skip the model service deployment and perform inference directly on the local machine. Refer to the example file: [example_eval_vlm_local](examples/example_eval_vlm_local.py) to configure the evaluation task.
Execute the evaluation task:
```shell
python examples/example_eval_vlm_local.py
```

##### (Optional) Deploy Judge Model
Deploy the local language model as a judge/extractor using ModelScope swift. For details, refer to: [ModelScope Swift LLM Deployment Guide](https://swift.readthedocs.io/en/latest/LLM/VLLM-inference-acceleration-and-deployment.html). If no judge model is deployed, exact matching will be used.

```shell
# Deploy qwen2-7b as a judge
CUDA_VISIBLE_DEVICES=1 swift deploy --model_type qwen2-7b-instruct --model_id_or_path models/Qwen2-7B-Instruct --port 8866
```

You **must configure the following environment variables for the judge model to be correctly invoked**:
```
OPENAI_API_KEY=EMPTY
OPENAI_API_BASE=http://127.0.0.1:8866/v1/chat/completions # api_base for the judge model
LOCAL_LLM=qwen2-7b-instruct # model_id for the judge model
```

##### Model Evaluation
Refer to the example file: [example_eval_vlm_swift](examples/example_eval_vlm_swift.py) to configure the evaluation task.

Execute the evaluation task:

```shell
python examples/example_eval_vlm_swift.py
```

### Local Dataset
You can use local dataset to evaluate the model without internet connection.
#### 1. Download and unzip the dataset
```shell
# set path to /path/to/workdir
wget https://modelscope.oss-cn-beijing.aliyuncs.com/open_data/benchmark/data.zip
unzip data.zip
```

#### 2. Use local dataset to evaluate the model
```shell
python evalscope/run.py --model ZhipuAI/chatglm3-6b --template-type chatglm3 --datasets arc --dataset-hub Local --dataset-args '{"arc": {"local_path": "/path/to/workdir/data/arc"}}' --limit 10

# Parameters:
# --dataset-hub: dataset sources: `ModelScope`, `Local`, `HuggingFace` (TO-DO) default to `ModelScope`
# --dataset-args: json format, key is the dataset name, value should be args for the dataset
```

#### 3. (Optional) Use local mode to submit evaluation task

```shell
# 1. Prepare the model local folder, the folder structure refers to chatglm3-6b, link: https://modelscope.cn/models/ZhipuAI/chatglm3-6b/files
# For example, download the model folder to the local path /path/to/ZhipuAI/chatglm3-6b

# 2. Execute the offline evaluation task
python evalscope/run.py --model /path/to/ZhipuAI/chatglm3-6b --template-type chatglm3 --datasets arc --dataset-hub Local --dataset-args '{"arc": {"local_path": "/path/to/workdir/data/arc"}}' --limit 10
```

### Use run_task function

#### 1. Configuration
```python
import torch
from evalscope.constants import DEFAULT_ROOT_CACHE_DIR

# Example configuration
your_task_cfg = {
'model_args': {'revision': None, 'precision': torch.float16, 'device_map': 'auto'},
'generation_config': {'do_sample': False, 'repetition_penalty': 1.0, 'max_new_tokens': 512},
'dataset_args': {},
'dry_run': False,
'model': 'ZhipuAI/chatglm3-6b',
'template_type': 'chatglm3',
'datasets': ['arc', 'hellaswag'],
'work_dir': DEFAULT_ROOT_CACHE_DIR,
'outputs': DEFAULT_ROOT_CACHE_DIR,
'mem_cache': False,
'dataset_hub': 'ModelScope',
'dataset_dir': DEFAULT_ROOT_CACHE_DIR,
'stage': 'all',
'limit': 10,
'debug': False
}

```

#### 2. Execute the task
```python
from evalscope.run import run_task

run_task(task_cfg=your_task_cfg)
```

### Arena Mode
The Arena mode allows multiple candidate models to be evaluated through pairwise battles, and can choose to use the AI Enhanced Auto-Reviewer (AAR) automatic evaluation process or manual evaluation to obtain the evaluation report. The process is as follows:
#### 1. Env preparation
```text
a. Data preparation, the question data format refers to: evalscope/registry/data/question.jsonl
b. If you need to use the automatic evaluation process (AAR), you need to configure the relevant environment variables. Taking the GPT-4 based auto-reviewer process as an example, you need to configure the following environment variables:
> export OPENAI_API_KEY=YOUR_OPENAI_API_KEY
```

#### 2. Configuration files
```text
Refer to : evalscope/registry/config/cfg_arena.yaml
Parameters:
questions_file: question data path
answers_gen: candidate model prediction result generation, supports multiple models, can control whether to enable the model through the enable parameter
reviews_gen: evaluation result generation, currently defaults to using GPT-4 as the Auto-reviewer, can control whether to enable this step through the enable parameter
elo_rating: ELO rating algorithm, can control whether to enable this step through the enable parameter, note that this step depends on the review_file must exist
```

#### 3. Execute the script
```shell
#Usage:
cd evalscope

# dry-run mode
python evalscope/run_arena.py -c registry/config/cfg_arena.yaml --dry-run

# Execute the script
python evalscope/run_arena.py --c registry/config/cfg_arena.yaml
```

#### 4. Visualization

```shell
# Usage:
streamlit run viz.py -- --review-file evalscope/registry/data/qa_browser/battle.jsonl --category-file evalscope/registry/data/qa_browser/category_mapping.yaml
```

### Single Model Evaluation Mode

In this mode, we only score the output of a single model, without pairwise comparison.
#### 1. Configuration file
```text
Refer to: evalscope/registry/config/cfg_single.yaml
Parameters:
questions_file: question data path
answers_gen: candidate model prediction result generation, supports multiple models, can control whether to enable the model through the enable parameter
reviews_gen: evaluation result generation, currently defaults to using GPT-4 as the Auto-reviewer, can control whether to enable this step through the enable parameter
rating_gen: rating algorithm, can control whether to enable this step through the enable parameter, note that this step depends on the review_file must exist
```
#### 2. Execute the script
```shell
#Example:
python evalscope/run_arena.py --c registry/config/cfg_single.yaml
```

### Baseline Model Comparison Mode

In this mode, we select the baseline model, and compare other models with the baseline model for scoring. This mode can easily add new models to the Leaderboard (just need to run the scoring with the new model and the baseline model).

#### 1. Configuration file
```text
Refer to: evalscope/registry/config/cfg_pairwise_baseline.yaml
Parameters:
questions_file: question data path
answers_gen: candidate model prediction result generation, supports multiple models, can control whether to enable the model through the enable parameter
reviews_gen: evaluation result generation, currently defaults to using GPT-4 as the Auto-reviewer, can control whether to enable this step through the enable parameter
rating_gen: rating algorithm, can control whether to enable this step through the enable parameter, note that this step depends on the review_file must exist
```
#### 2. Execute the script
```shell
# Example:
python evalscope/run_arena.py --c registry/config/cfg_pairwise_baseline.yaml
```

## Datasets list

| DatasetName | Link | Status | Note |
|--------------------|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------|------|
| `mmlu` | [mmlu](https://modelscope.cn/datasets/modelscope/mmlu/summary) | Active | |
| `ceval` | [ceval](https://modelscope.cn/datasets/modelscope/ceval-exam/summary) | Active | |
| `gsm8k` | [gsm8k](https://modelscope.cn/datasets/modelscope/gsm8k/summary) | Active | |
| `arc` | [arc](https://modelscope.cn/datasets/modelscope/ai2_arc/summary) | Active | |
| `hellaswag` | [hellaswag](https://modelscope.cn/datasets/modelscope/hellaswag/summary) | Active | |
| `truthful_qa` | [truthful_qa](https://modelscope.cn/datasets/modelscope/truthful_qa/summary) | Active | |
| `competition_math` | [competition_math](https://modelscope.cn/datasets/modelscope/competition_math/summary) | Active | |
| `humaneval` | [humaneval](https://modelscope.cn/datasets/modelscope/humaneval/summary) | Active | |
| `bbh` | [bbh](https://modelscope.cn/datasets/modelscope/bbh/summary) | Active | |
| `race` | [race](https://modelscope.cn/datasets/modelscope/race/summary) | Active | |
| `trivia_qa` | [trivia_qa](https://modelscope.cn/datasets/modelscope/trivia_qa/summary) | To be intergrated | |

## Leaderboard
The LLM Leaderboard aims to provide an objective and comprehensive evaluation standard and platform to help researchers and developers understand and compare the performance of models on various tasks on ModelScope.

Refer to : [Leaderboard](https://modelscope.cn/leaderboard/58/ranking?type=free)

## Experiments and Results
Refer to : [Experiments](./resources/experiments.md)

## Model Serving Performance Evaluation
Refer to : [Perf](evalscope/perf/README.md)

## TO-DO List
- [x] Agents evaluation
- [ ] vLLM
- [ ] Distributed evaluating
- [x] Multi-modal evaluation
- [ ] Benchmarks
- [ ] GAIA
- [ ] GPQA
- [x] MBPP
- [ ] Auto-reviewer
- [ ] Qwen-max